IPv6 only networks: experiences

2017 November 6
by Daniel Lakeland

T-Mobile has been ipv6 only on their mobile network, at least for Android phones, for quite some time now, at least a year or more. Apple required that all apps in their app store be IPv6 only read by June 2016 or so... the IPv6 transition is in full swing right now. Here's the traffic graph from Google:

Google IPv6 traffic as of 2017-11-06

IPv6 traffic at google globally as of 2017-11-06

I use SIP based phones, and to tell you the truth, they have a lot of problems... most of which are caused by the non-end-to-end nature of modern ipv4. NAT means that if a SIP server needs to open a connection and tell your phone what to do, such as that the other end is putting the call on hold, you are screwed. Instead, your phone has to keep a connection open to the server at all times, and so even a half-second glitch in your wifi can reset TCP connections and lead to dropped calls. (this is particularly true for SIP over TCP or more importantly SIP over TLS... who wants coffee-shop snoopers to record phone calls? Well it's easy with wireshark and an unencrypted SIP call so use TLS + SRTP).

Anyway, other things don't work that well over ipv4 either: ever wanted to reach your home computer from a remote location and pull a file off of it? It's basically impossible. Similarly for screen-sharing/remote control. There are tons of hacks that kinda make this work, but they're insecure and usually involve giving a totally unknown third party control over your computers (some cloud provider) or port-forwarding, and a lot of other hackishness. Third parties employ people, some of whom get disgruntled. Some of whom stalk their disgruntled exes online... Think I'm joking? I'm not. Read the news:  so "fixing" the ipv4 brokenness by buying a "cloud service" that lets you connect to your home network through some proxy server run by Google/Samsung/CloudsRUs or whatever is a terrible idea.

So, it makes lots of sense to want to eliminate IPv4 as soon as possible: for one thing, it makes the internet work again, for another, it's much easier to administrate, for a third, it means you don't have two configurations to manage, finally, it just supports more devices on your network in a trivially easy way, and there are lots of devices these days.

In order to do this, you need to map the entire IPv4 internet into a tiny little corner of the IPv6 internet, and have a translator. This is called NAT64 and DNS64. Google provides a DNS64 service:  so that takes care of that, you just need to advertise their servers, or have a caching server that uses them as upstream. And, to do the protocol mapping, you need Tayga on your router:  problem solved. This is the technique that T-Mobile uses to make things relatively transparent for your phone.

So, here are my experiences with turning off ipv4 entirely:

  1. SIP calls were broken initially. Unfortunately none of the sip providers do ipv6, so you still need ipv4 connectivity, and more to the point many ATAs don't do IPv6 so that becomes broken. The way to fix this is via "topology hiding" at a sip proxy like Opensips. I'll give a detailed explanation elsewhere. Once I got this fixed, calls drop a lot less and generally things work better, including better audio quality (no doubt all that carrier grade NAT reduces real-time performance of the switching gear in your ISP, and ipv6 bypasses all that).
  2. NFS4 with kerberos encryption just works exactly the way it should. I can access my fileserver from anywhere on the ipv6 web.
  3. I still can't figure out how to get OpenVPN to push ipv6 routes to clients properly. But it does work in so far as it recognizes the ipv6 commands and spits out meaningful logs. I just didn't get the config right.
  4. FireTV Stick is flaky. It seems like if you're broadcasting a DNS entry on your router advertisements, the FireTV stick decides it doesn't have an internet connection. This is true even if you turn on ipv4 for it and hand it a DHCP lease. Hmm... but if you leave it alone for several hours, magically it starts working fine. Clearly a software update is in order Amazon.
  5. Kindle Fire tablets work fine. Flawlessly for all their basic functions.
  6. Minecraft pocket edition on the Kindle Fire works fine on its own, but doesn't do any LAN games. If you give it an ipv4 it works for LAN games. Sigh. This is a known issue apparently. I suspect it will get better as the new, one month old code base gets ironed out. Also, using a server is recommended, but the new code base broke all the servers. Wait a few months if you play minecraft a lot (or your kids do, whatever). New code base seems to demand an XBox One login even if you want to play on your own server. No thanks Microsoft. I consider these things bugs, or worse yet the XBox login thing is malicious spyware behavior.
  7. Linux desktops, MacOS desktops, and Windows Desktops all work totally flawlessly, including raspberry pi. My wife who is a mac user, didn't know I turned off ipv4 until a week afterwards when I told her. Of course she knew I broke the phone system, but I've done that before. Her Mac just worked. There were a few glitches but they turned out to be unrelated (Right about the same time, Google wanted her to upgrade from the "Drive" client to the "Sync" client... so her Drive stopped working, but not because ipv6 just because of google's new system).
  8. Android phones work flawlessly. In fact they seem to work better under ipv6 only to tell you the truth. I think this is the end-to-end nature of the network, no NAT bullshit breaking your communications.

So, if you want to replicate this experiment and ditch the broken old internet protocol here's what you need to replicate my setup:

  • A router running linux.
  • Firehol firewall software.
  • DNSmasq LAN management software (does DNS caching, DHCP, SLAAC, router advertisements, DHCPv6, local DNS for your LAN, etc).
  • Tayga on the router to do NAT64
  • The google DNS64 server info on the above linked page.
  • Some knowledge of how ipv6 works.
  • An ISP that provides ipv6 natively: ATT, Comcast, Spectrum/Charter/TWC, and Cox all do this to a substantial degree.
  • Wide DHCPv6 client to request prefixes from your ISP
  • Alternatively, get a router that runs LEDE (the more up-to-date project that came from OpenWRT). It handles ipv6 pretty much flawlessly out of the box, I just have slightly more requirements for my router than average, so I run it on an Intel machine running Debian.


No comments yet

Leave a Reply

Note: You can use basic XHTML in your comments. Your email address will never be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS